The Last Watchman of Old Cairo


  • The Last Watchman of Old Cairo 
    by Michael David Lukas (Spiegel and Grau) March 2018
  • In 40 words or less: Mixing historical figures with a centuries-long fictional story, Lukas brings to life the centuries-long intertwining of the Muslim and Jewish communities. In the modern thread, a graduate student heads to Cairo to learn more about the father he barely knew.
  • Genre: Historical fiction
  • Locale: Cairo, Egypt; Berkeley, CA; and England
  • Time: 11th/12th century to the end of the 20th century
  • The true story of centuries worth of documents discovered at the end of the 19th century is a centerpiece of the novel.

Until the middle of the 20th century, Jews and Muslims lived side by in Cairo as they had for almost a millennium. In the 1950’s, Egypt’s Jews were expelled, emigrating to Israel, France, and the United States.  A Jewish girl and Muslim boy, childhood friends, were reunited briefly in Paris in 1973, separating again before they knew of her pregnancy. Their child, Joseph, was raised in the US, only visiting his Egyptian family during an occasional summer, and maintaining his ties with his father through stories his father would tell over the phone.

Joseph’s father was the last in the line of Al-Raqb men who had served as night watchmen at Ben Ezra synagogue for generations. While not of high status, this was a position of great trust. After his father’s death, Joseph received a box with a piece of paper in Arabic and Hebrew, suggesting that Joseph should travel to Cairo. Joseph takes a leave from his graduate studies to connect with his late father and the secret he wanted to share.

In the late 1890s, Scottish twin sister adventurers and amateur scholars, Agnes Smith Lewis and Margaret Dunlop Gibson, brought fragments of Hebrew texts to Rabbi Solomon Schechter, a researcher in England. An expedition was arranged for Schechter to evaluate and bring back material from the Geniza, the repository for Hebrew sacred writings that may be torn or otherwise discarded, in the Ben Ezra Synagogue. While Schechter was in Cairo, Agnes and Margaret paid a visit while en route to the Holy Land. They, too, were interested in acquiring documents.  Michael David Lukas has made this on-site research project and interactions with prominent members of the Cairo Jewish and political communities a major storyline in the novel. Having previously read detailed accounts of this project, referenced by Lukas in notes about his research, this fact-based view into life in Cairo during this period is particularly intriguing.

Joseph’s visit with his family is not without some bumps. Culturally he is American through and through so there is the necessary adaptation to both pace and style. Additionally, Joseph is hesitant to reveal aspects of his life and plans to the family. Joseph is gay, and that plays a part, though doesn’t define the story.

When historical fiction is very successful it may entice the reader to explore periods or places in history that previously were unfamiliar.  The Last Watchman of Old Cairo does this and much more. Joseph’s Cairo is not that of the Arab Spring. It speaks to a time shortly before, when the flavor of the city was still captured in families with centuries of history. And just as the last watchman has died off, so has the Old Cairo that was home to people of all the Abrahamic religions, living and working together.

 

SaveSaveSaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSaveSaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSaveSaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

Facebooktwitterlinkedinmailby feather

‘Memento Park’, a novel of lost and found

  • Memento Park by Mark Sarvas (Farrar, Straus and Giroux) March 2018
  • In 40 words or less: Matt Santos, a B-list actor, plays parts on screen and in his own life. A phone call suggesting he’s the rightful owner of a painting seized by the Nazis in 1944 raises questions about his identity, his family, and the choices he’s made.
  • Genre: Literary fiction
  • Locale: United States and Hungary
  • Time: Contemporary

Matt Santos seems to be living the Los Angeles dream. A regular role in a series. Living with his girlfriend Tracy, a model and activist working to free a death row inmate she believes wrongly convicted. Things are rarely what they seem. Matt isn’t really into the show and Tracy is spending a lot of time with a lawyer on the case. Out of the blue, a phone call from a New York law firm upends the delicate balance of their lives.

The lawyer insists that Matt may be the rightful owner of a painting wrongly transferred during WWII and now in the restitution process. Matt argues he knows nothing about it and is told his father has declined any claims in Matt’s favor. Matt has had a fractious relationship with his father and wants nothing to do with the painting or his father. Tracy has been the go-between for father and son, and a weekend visit cross country by Gabor does little to assuage the ill feelings.

With this as the background, Matt begins the search for the truth about the painting, its ownership, and the history of his family in Hungary during the war. The attorney provided Matt for this process is Rachel, a young woman from a traditional Jewish family, whose relationship with her father is in stark contrast to Matt’s. The richness of Rachel’s family life, despite their modest means, awakens a mix of curiosity and envy towards Judaism. The discovery the other possible owner of the painting is a woman rabbi further adds to the complexity.

In Memento Park Mark Sarvas has written several stories swirling around one another. The story of Matt the actor touches on the emptiness of a life built on good looks and mediocre acting skills. Matt’s research into the life of the (fictitious) artist provides his first look into the struggles of the years between the wars and the toll it took on individuals and Jews, in particular.

Throughout the novel, Matt’s ongoing yearning for his father’s approval/love and his conditioned response when disappointed is the real grabber. It is only through the larger quest surrounding the painting that Matt learns of the experiences that shaped his father’s childhood and made him such a difficult man.  Coming to terms with it all is key to Matt reclaiming his life.

While the Holocaust and the infamous history behind the Shoes on the Danube Bank memorial are critical to the novel, I wouldn’t characterize it as a part of that genre.  This is a story of family and the secrets that color every aspect of life. Achieving this balance requires a delicate touch and Mark Sarvas has carried it off. The success of Memento Park is weaving together all the elements into cohesive work without straining credulity. The result is a novel with interesting plot twists that will provide book groups with ample material for discussion.

 

 

SaveSaveSaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

Facebooktwitterlinkedinmailby feather

Nature, nurture or fate? ‘The Immortalists’

  • The Immortalists by Chloe Benjamin (G.P. Putnam’s Sons) January 2018; Penguin Audio, Maggie Hoffman – Narrator
  • In 40 words or less: Four young siblings, ages 9 – 13, seek out a fortune teller who predicts the date of each one’s death, unknown to the others. One by one, Benjamin reveals their lives, times, and choices, always with death at hand.
  • Genre: Literary fiction
  • Locale: VariousUSA
  • Time: 1969 – 2010
  • Chloe Benjamin adeptly mixes iconic American locales with carefully selected elements of history and popular culture to tell a family story and ask the recurring question, “How would you live your life if you knew the number of your days?”

The Immortalists has haunted me for months. So appropriate for a novel created on the premise that knowledge, kept secret, may dictate the choices of one’s entire life.

Varya, Daniel, Klara, and Simon Gold are the children of Saul, a tailor, and Gertie, living on the Lower East Side in 1969. The children are second generation Jewish Americans, living in a community and world markedly different from their elders. Having heard rumors of a psychic, the four seek her out, and each is told the date of his/her death and that they must not share that information with anyone, ever.

One by one, Chloe Benjamin reveals each child’s path to adulthood. Though never discussed, this one afternoon is a burden that the four carry throughout their lives. In many ways, it is the secrets more than the information itself that color the relationships within the family and with those they touch.

It takes particular skill to craft a novel that balances the isolation and connection of a family from childhood. Chloe Benjamin uses carefully chose locales and time periods to reveal each personality and reflect the defining and oppressive nature of each person’s countdown clock.

In the news and in individual conversations, the devasting cost of keeping secrets is a common topic. As I turn over my continuing reaction to The Immortalists, I wonder how many choices in life are responses to secrets, overriding nature and nurture with fear.

This book is worthy of all the accolades it has received. I listened to the audiobook, and while I had small issues with the narrator’s voice choice for the mother, I was completely caught up from the first moment. It is the mark of a beautifully crafted novel when the reader wants to intervene in the lives of the characters. When the characters stay long after the final page, that’s a book that must be shared.

 

 

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSaveSaveSave

Facebooktwitterlinkedinmailby feather

Be transported with ‘Gateway to the Moon’

  • Gateway to the Moon by Mary Morris (Nan A. Talese, Doubleday) April 2018
  • In 40 words or less: Brilliant storytelling and character development propel the reader from the Spanish Inquisition/Expulsion and Columbus’s exploration to the desert of New Mexico five centuries later. Morris weaves together history, astronomy, human frailty, and the strength of family bonds across generations.
  • Genre: Literary fiction/Historical fiction
  • Locale: Spain, Portugal, New World, and New Mexico
  • Time: 1492-1500 and 1992
  • A rare novel combining two periods of discovery. Historical figures are carefully researched and noted as such in the listing of characters and families. Gateway to the Moon is also a coming of age story for a teen whose connection to the stars is his solace and path to the future.

As long as I’ve been in book groups I’ve searched for an engrossing novel that brings to life the conflicted period of Spain’s ascendancy as a world power and the injustices and horrors of the Inquisition and the Jews expulsion from Spain. Even less common are writings about those along on Columbus’s first expedition and what may have transpired with those left behind as the ships returned to Spain. Finally, there is a book that fills this void.

Mary Morris has the special hand required to mix history and historical figures with fictional characters with due respect to both. Even before Chapter 1 begins, Morris provides a framework for navigating the pathway from fact to fiction and back.

Miguel Torres has his feet in the dust of Entrada de la Luna and his eyes in the stars. A loner, he is fascinated by space and his thirst is recognized by his science teacher who works to keep him on the straight and narrow. Poverty and boredom are often the ticket to “juvie”, a brief trip Miguel has already taken. A chance sighting of an ad for someone to help with two small boys after school may be the way for Miguel to afford a better telescope and car money. Respectful of his elders, but in large measure raising himself, he’s dutiful about heading home Friday nights where his mother prepares the trailer for candle lighting.

The story shifts 500 years to 1492. Among those on Columbus’s ships as they left Spain in 1492 were linguists, navigators, and cartographers from the crypto-Jewish community who lives would have been at risk as the Inquisition and Expulsion pressures increased. Separated from their families, these men and boys held out hope they’d find a new home for themselves and their families at the end of their voyage. Through Luis de Torres, Columbus’s scribe, others on the ships and those left behind, Morris richly describes the fragmenting of families even as Columbus anticipates riches and glory.

This is a book filled with beautiful language. Descriptions provide just enough detail to conjure up pictures without detracting from the characters or plot. While Columbus and Miguel look to the stars for orientation, each of the other characters must adapt to the unexpected and does so in a fitting and natural way which isn’t easy to pull off.  Chapter titles provide orientation in time and place, and the character lists and genealogy at the front of the book are there in the event the reader is momentarily distracted from the story’s flow.

The Jazz Palace, Mary Morris’s previous book set in Chicago during the early years of the 20th century, took on history, the development of jazz, discrimination, and families. While that was a big undertaking, Gateway to the Moon takes on a bigger challenge and brings it home. Whether your taste runs to coming of age stories, hidden communities or history brought to life, you will find it in Gateway to the Moon. This is an ideal book for book groups and will quickly push its way to the top of your to-be-read pile.

 

 

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

Facebooktwitterlinkedinmailby feather

1920’s, the birth of the FBI, and ‘Killers of the Flower Moon’

  • Killers of the Flower Moon by David Grann (Doubleday) 2017
  • In 40 words or less: After the Osage Tribe was relocated to Oklahoma, oil was discovered making the Osage the wealthiest people in the USA. Pillars of the white community systematically stripped them of their rights, money, and lives.
  • Genre: History
  • Locale: Oklahoma and Washington, DC
  • Time: 1920’s
  • Another untold chapter in US history brought to life almost a century later. The corruption that decimated the lives and assets of untold Osage family members also claimed the lives of some seeking to provide justice. Grann’s careful research sheds light on the formation of the FBI, the first national police force.

Even as students, we are aware the history we are taught is limited. Not only do the winners of wars write the histories, but many stories are buried out of fear or by others to whitewash the truth. For many of us, the early days of the FBI are tied to Prohibition, bootlegging and the Chicago gangsters of that era. These were the impetus for the creation of the first national police force which became the FBI. It was a force made up of accountants and lawyers in anticipation of fighting smuggling, tax evasion and the like.

Something strange was happening to Mollie Burkhart, her two sisters, and mother. Mollie was part of the Osage aristocracy – lovely homes, house servants, well-educated – and very wealthy. One sister died of an unexplained wasting disease, their mother was inexplicably ill, and then Anna disappeared. Anna was a bit wild but had strong ties to her family and had no reason to run. While she was seen right before her disappearance, the trail quickly went cold. There were too many odd things happening within the Osage that didn’t add up and some outside help was needed.

This is a many-layered story of racism and sanctioned plundering. Indians, and more particularly women, were considered incapable of managing their own affairs so guardians were appointed. White husbands were granted the right to control their wives’ allotments. And this system was ingrained in the lawyers, insurance agents and bankers of the community. These cabals endangered the safety of anyone questioning the system. It was into this that an odd undercover operation of the FBI run by a Washington outsider tried to shed some light.

Killers of the Flower Moon is deserving of all the accolades it has received. Every line is researched in detail, giving the reader a rare opportunity to see the crimes unfolding almost contemporaneously. This is very important history beyond Oklahoma and is finally getting attention. Book groups, even those primarily reading fiction, will find David Grann’s telling compelling.

SaveSaveSaveSave

SaveSaveSaveSaveSaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

Facebooktwitterlinkedinmailby feather